Your cat is talking to you at dinner. Not in words (that would be a whole other conversation), but in tails, ears, shoulder glances and the occasional dramatic walk-off. Plenty of us consider our cat the toughest food critic in the house, so it pays to know what the critic is actually saying.
We asked cat behaviour expert Saba Vasconcelos to translate. Consider this your fur-ther education.
The tail tells all
Before you panic about a “fussy” cat, start with the basics. “Cats actually communicate a lot at mealtime. We just need to know what we’re looking for!” says Saba.
A cat who’s relaxed and looking forward to dinner “might approach with their tail upright, ears in a relaxed position and body moving quite freely. You might see them rubbing against you, meowing or following you around while you’re preparing their food.” In other words, you’re not the chef, you’re the paw-rtered staff.
But don’t fixate on one behaviour. “I always encourage cat parents to observe their cat’s personality and body language rather than focusing on one behaviour.” Smell, texture, familiarity, environment and even how predictable the routine is all play a part. So if your cat suddenly gets hesitant about the bowl, Saba says, “I wouldn’t immediately assume they’re being fussy. I’d look at the bigger picture. Has something changed in their environment? Is another cat nearby? Have you changed the feeding location or their usual routine?”
Her top tip: “Learn your cat’s individual personality and behaviour patterns, not just their body language. When you understand what’s normal for your individual cat, it becomes much easier to recognise when something changes.”
Is your cat truly purr-fectly content?
“A content cat is generally a cat who feels safe enough to focus on eating,” says Saba. Look for “relaxed body language, a comfortable posture and a willingness to approach their bowl without hesitation.”
Here’s the part that might make you paws mid-scroll. Saba pays particular attention to “whether the cat can eat without constantly monitoring their surroundings.” In multi-cat homes, a cat who inhales dinner or keeps glancing over their shoulder might look like a food-loving legend. “Owners might think, ‘Oh, my cat just loves food!’ But sometimes that behaviour can indicate resource tension or resource guarding.”
It’s not always dramatic, either. “Resource guarding isn’t always obvious aggression. Sometimes it’s subtle, such as one cat hovering near another’s feeding area, blocking access or making the other cat uncomfortable enough to eat quickly or avoid the space altogether.”
Other red flags include “suddenly walking away, eating only when their owner is present, hesitating to approach the bowl or becoming unusually vigilant.” The big takeaway: “Eating the food doesn’t automatically mean the cat is comfortable.”
And if appetite or eating habits change suddenly? “I’d always recommend ruling out a medical cause first.” Your vet is the first stop, not the last resort.
Two claw-ful myths, busted
Myth one: scratching around the bowl means “this is disgusting.” Not so fast. “People sometimes think their cat is telling them the food is disgusting! But scratching around food can be a natural food-covering behaviour linked to instinctive safety and resource-related behaviours.” In the wild, “covering leftover food may help reduce smells that could attract other animals, including competitors or potential threats.” So when your cat gives the bowl a little fur-nish, “it doesn’t automatically mean they dislike what you’ve served!”
Myth two: food and water belong side by side. It looks tidy to us, but cats may see it differently. “As natural predators and obligate carnivores, cats have evolved behaviours around food, hunting and accessing safe drinking water.” One commonly suggested explanation is that cats may prefer drinking away from feeding or prey sites, though Saba is careful to add that “we shouldn’t assume every cat has that specific concern.”
Her advice: “Offer water in separate locations from food and treat both as important resources rather than automatically grouping everything together.” This matters most in multi-cat households, where one-stop feeding stations “can create resource tension, competition or opportunities for one cat to block another’s access.”
The myth Saba most wants to retire is the idea that every unusual feeding behaviour means a cat is being fussy or difficult. It’s a tough one to shake, given that Fancy Feast research found 60% of Aussie cat owners consider their cat the toughest food critic in their household. But, says Saba, “Cats aren’t trying to give us a hard time. Their behaviour is information, and our job is to understand what it might be telling us.”

Dinner is a meow-ment worth having
Mealtime isn’t just refuelling. “I think mealtime is one of the most underestimated opportunities we have to build a positive relationship with our cats,” says Saba.
The secret ingredient is consistency. “Cats generally benefit from predictability. When something positive happens consistently, it can become a reassuring part of their everyday routine.” She encourages cat parents to “connect their cat’s feeding routine with their own everyday lifestyle,” such as feeding shortly after waking or when you get home from work. “They might hear you getting out of bed in the morning and come running, or greet you excitedly when you walk through the door after work because they know something positive is about to happen.”
It’s the little cues that add up: “The time of day, the sound of you preparing their meal, where the bowl is placed and what usually happens next.” And the benefit flows both ways. “What’s particularly lovely is that the person providing the food can also become associated with those positive experiences.”
Aussie owners seem to agree. Research commissioned by Fancy Feast found that feeding time has evolved beyond simply serving dinner, becoming one of the most meaningful daily rituals shared between cats and their owners. 55% see mealtime as one of their most meaningful daily rituals, and 58% say it’s one of their favourite interactions with their cat. It also points to Australians increasingly prioritising quality time and connection through their pets’ mealtime routines. “That makes complete sense to me,” says Saba. “My philosophy has always been that cat parenting shouldn’t feel like a chore.”
Ritual is exactly what’s behind the new Fancy Feast Gems, a pyramid mousse pâté topped with savoury gravy (Chicken, Salmon and Tuna) that comes with its own “Peel. Flip. Reveal.” routine. Saba sees the thinking: “Feeding is one of the primary ways people care for their cats, so shape, texture and routine can all play a role in how cats experience their food and the bonding moment. It’s no surprise owners are putting more thought into creating mealtimes their cats will enjoy.” Around 40% of owners already regularly introduce new flavours or textures to keep mealtimes interesting, so plenty of us are happy to put in the effort.
But you don’t need a fancy production. “You don’t need to make every moment complicated. A calm, enjoyable feeding routine can be a lovely way to build trust and connection over time.”
The ten-minute cat-titude check
Saba’s favourite exercise is to watch a cat eat for ten minutes, and she’s not only watching the cat. “I’m observing the entire environment and what’s happening around the cat.” Here’s her checklist, which you can run at home tonight:
- How confidently does your cat approach? “Do they walk straight up to the bowl? Are they relaxed and excited? Do they hesitate or spend time checking the surroundings near food?”
- What’s the setting like? “Is the bowl in a quiet, comfortable location? Is there another cat nearby? Does the cat have space to eat without being interrupted?”
- How do you fit in? “Is the cat comfortable with the person nearby? Does the owner constantly interrupt, move the bowl or try to encourage the cat to eat? Or is the cat able to enjoy their meal without pressure?”
- What happens afterwards? “Does the cat walk away comfortably? Do they seem relaxed? Or are they still monitoring their surroundings?”
One caveat from the expert: “I wouldn’t claim I could diagnose a behaviour problem from watching one mealtime!” But those ten minutes can offer “really useful clues about the cat’s confidence, their feeding environment, their relationship with other cats and the routines within that household.” After all, “a behaviour rarely exists in isolation. What happens around the behaviour is often just as important as the behaviour itself.”

Dinner is served: The Feline Feast
To celebrate this growing mealtime trend, Fancy Feast has partnered with chef Nelly Robinson and NEL Restaurant to create The Feline Feast, a fine dining experience that brings the insight to life.
The details:
- What: The Feline Feast, a free dining experience created by Fancy Feast with Nelly Robinson and NEL Restaurant
- When: 2 November
- Who: open to the public
- Cost: complimentary reservations, available on a first come, first served basis
- Where and how to book: NEL Restaurant, via nelrestaurant.com.au/the-feline-feast
The fur-nal word
Your cat has been giving you feedback this whole time, in tail flicks, ear angles and the odd over-the-shoulder glance. As Saba puts it, “Sometimes the smallest everyday interactions can tell us a great deal about how a cat is experiencing their world.” So tonight, pull up a chair, watch the show and let your cat be the critic. Just don’t expect a five-star review in writing.














